When the large deck appeared on the Elder Building above (now MSC) it stuck out like a sore thumb, and was so damaging to the heritage roofscapes of the listed West End, that it was assumed to be just a serious error that would be soon rectified and removed.
But no, months later it is still there. By day it disfigures one of the most important buildings in Fremantle, and diminishes the landmark quality of its cupola on the corner of Phillimore and Cliff Streets. By night, as seen above, it resembles a flying saucer landing in the West End.
The Fremantle Society has been shocked to learn that the deck with its louvred canopy roof was deemed by Fremantle Council officers to be ‘not unduly obtrusive’ and that the Heritage Council, which Mayor Pettitt sits on, raised no objections.
There are now endless examples of damage to heritage buildings in Fremantle like this, and there do not appear to be any rules any longer. The rule book has been thrown out.
This disgraceful situation will be a focus of the Fremantle Society as it tries to make heritage once again a subject of importance to Fremantle Council. Since Fremantle Society committee member Agnieshka Kiera left council as heritage architect, there has been no strong advocate for heritage on council.
With 2020 vision, we will work to bring back the scrapped heritage committee, the scrapped heritage grants fund, the scrapped 1.25% of rates to heritage projects, the scrapped annual heritage awards, and the scrapped annual local history awards.